Pray, Montana — Montana Town Sold After Going Up for Sale

Summary: The historic town of Pray, Montana, located in Paradise Valley, officially sold on August 4, 2025. The ±5-acre property included commercial buildings, vacation rentals, and future development potential, and had been listed for $2.6 million. 

If you are looking for other interesting opportunities in Montana, check out this post. 

Timeline of the Sale

August 7, 2025 – SOLD
The Pray, Montana listing closed on August 4, 2025.

June 17, 2025 – Under Contract
As of June 16, 2025, the property was under contract.

September 16, 2024 – Listed for Sale
The historic town of Pray, Montana officially hit the market.

Where Is Pray, Montana?

Pray is tucked into the heart of Paradise Valley, just 30 minutes from Livingston and Gardiner, the only year-round entrance to Yellowstone National Park. The town is only minutes from Chico Hot Springs, Sage Lodge, and the Old Saloon, making it an attractive location for both tourism and investment. 

Listing Details

The roughly 5-acre property includes a post office (leased by the U.S. Postal Service), the historic Pray General Store, multiple short-term rental units, and space for future development all for $2.6 million.

Address: 1392 E River Rd, Pray, MT
List Price: $2.6 million
Lot Size: ±5 acres
Current Use: Commercial, residential, and vacation rental

Property Features

• Historic Pray General Store – dating back to the early 1900s

• Remodeled duplex (2019)

• Three Amish-built log cabins used as vacation rentals

• U.S. Post Office lease (long-term tenant)

• Approved septic system for 8 additional cabins

• Unzoned property – no building restrictions

   

Looking for more unique real estate opportunities in Montana? 👉 Click here to explore other properties or sign up for our newsletter for the latest updates.

A Brief History of Pray

Founded in 1907 by Valentine Eggar and named after U.S. Congressman Charles Nelson Pray, the town has long been a fixture of the Paradise Valley community, long before the area became a destination for travelers and adventurers from around the world.

For over 20 years, Pray was lovingly cared for by Barbara Walker, who inherited the town from her husband’s family. Acting as landlord, caretaker, and even its unofficial mayor, Barbara’s stewardship helped preserve its charm and historical character. She sold the property in 2018, and in 2025 the opportunity appeared for someone to carry on the legacy of this Montana town.

This property was listed by Michael Rutkowski, eXp Realty, LLC.

Photo credit: Big Sky Country MLS